In collaboration with Iranian Watershed Management Association

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 MSc., Combat Desertification Department, Desert Studies Faculty, Semnan University, Semnan, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Arid Lands Mnagement Department, Desert Studies Faculty, Semnan University, Semnan, Iran

3 Assistant Professor, Combat Desertification Department, Desert Studies Faculty, Semnan University, Semnan, Iran

4 Associate Professor, Soil Conservation and Watershed Research Institute, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Over the past decades, excessive and unplanned exploitation of watershed resources (soil, water, and vegetation) has led to a decline in their overall health. One approach that can play a preventive role in this regard is to focus on alternative livelihoods, especially in the ecotourism and tourism sectors. Therefore, it is necessary to identify and assess geosites and geomorphosites across different regions. The aim of the present study is to evaluate the tourism value of geomorphotourism landscapes in the Hableh-Rud basin using the Pralong model.
 
Materials and methods
To evaluate these geosites, detailed information about the studied area was obtained through field and library studies. The Hableh-Rud watershed, with an area of 1,265,977 hectares, is located between 52°39' to 53°08' east longitude and 35°26' to 35°57' north latitude in Tehran and Semnan provinces. From among the geomorphic sites in the Hableh-Rud region, three sites were selected, and a detailed profile was prepared for each geomorphosite. The sites include Rudafshan Cave in the west of Damavand city, Khumdeh Spring, and Vashi Gorge. In this research, based on the Pralong model, a survey of experts knowledgeable about the study area and visiting tourists (30 people) was conducted using a simple random sampling method. The Pralong model specifically evaluates the tourism quality of geomorphosites and their potential for use. In this model, the tourism value of a site is calculated as the average of its aesthetic, scientific, cultural, and functional-economic values. Specific criteria and scales have been defined to determine the value of each aspect of the tourism quality of geomorphic sites. Accordingly, the tourism score of a site is the average of these four criteria.
 
Results and discussion
After analyzing the data, it was determined that, among the three selected sites, the Vashi Gorge geosite has the highest geomorphotourism value, with a tourism score of 0.54 and an average use potential value of 0.68. Factors that have increased the value and importance of the Vashi Gorge include its uniqueness at the national level, pleasant and cool climate, distinctive geomorphological forms and unique engravings on the stone wall of the gorge, as well as the scenery of the waterfall and the presence of a very beautiful meadow surrounding it. This gorge, with its raging river and cool water, has attracted many visitors and tourists. The Rudafshan Cave geosites ranked second with a tourism score of (0.41). The reasons for this ranking can be attributed to the concentration of geomorphological phenomena in a small area (inside the cave), its location next to Rudafshan village, and natural attractions (Delichai River, the pristine nature of the village with green and tall trees). The Khumdeh mineral spring with a score of (0.31) ranked third. The reasons include the unique character of the spring in the region, its therapeutic properties, its proximity to the flowing Hableh-Rud River, the beautiful surrounding nature, and easy access via an asphalted road. The evaluations show that the tourism values of the geomorphological landforms in the Vashi Gorge region are mainly due to the high scores for physical beauty, cultural value, and scientific value of this landform. The interrelationships between these values should be considered. In general, across all landforms, the aesthetic score and the scientific score are similar.
 
Conclusions
According to the results, the highest tourism quality and value belong to the Vashi Gorge, and the lowest belongs to the Khumdeh mineral spring. However, except for the Vashi Gorge, the scores for scientific and aesthetic quality, as well as use potential, in the other landforms are very low. It is necessary to provide these landforms with the facilities needed by tourists to ensure optimal utilization of these areas. The tourism value of these sites depends on the high quality of their aesthetic appeal and their cultural and scientific qualities. Factors such as difficult access, the lack of amenities and proper services, and insufficient attention to geotourism have contributed to the relatively low total calculated scores.
 

Keywords

Ara, H., Shahvardi Qahfarkhi, Sh., Kharazi, P., Kianian, M.K., 2013. Evaluation of the tourism potential of dissolved landforms based on the modified Pralong model of Cochin (and the Pralong model) (case study: Se Ghar Sarab, Seyed Isa and Chehal Pele in Chahar Mahal and Bakhtiari Province). Tour. Manag. Stud. Qtly. 9(25), 158-142 (in Persian).
Arabshahi, M., Behbodi, O., Shah Ebrahimi, R.A., 2015. Identifying and ranking effective welfare factors in religious tourism in Mashhad using multi-criteria decision-making techniques (AHP). Great Khorasan Res. 7(23), 75-88 (in Persian).
Ardakani, Tahereh, Daneh Kar, A., Karami, M., Aqiqi, H., 2011. Zoning of Chabahar Bay using multi-variable decision-making model for concentrated recreational use. J. Geogr. Surv. of Space 1(1), 1-20 (in Persian).
Baghbanan, P., Ahmiad, A., Karimi, A.A., 2021. Investigating the effect of climate change on hydrological changes in Hablehrood catchment. J. Clim. Res., Scienti. Quart. 2(5), 27-40.
Barghi, H., Rahimi, D., Rahimi, R., 2014. Locating campsite construction in tourism target villages using geographic information system and AHP model (case study: Abyaneh village). Spatial Plan. J. 5(2), 55-74 (in Persian).
Ebrahimzadeh, I., Hafez Rezazadeh, M., Daraee, M., 2013. Optimal planning and location of urban tourism facilities and infrastructures using GIS, case study: Semnan city. Geogr. and Dev. 12 (35), 33-48 (in Persian).
Fakhr Jamali, H., Sahraee Nejad, N., Mousavi Fatemi, H., 2021. Zoning analysis of the sustainable development of rural ecology using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), case study: Sardabeh Village of Ardabil Province. J. Sustain. Archt. Urban Des. 9(2), 65-77 (in Persian).
Foruzande Shahraki, G., Kahram, A., Laqaei, H., 2013. Locating the design of the tourist village in "Love Valley". Environ. Sci. Tech. 3, 83- 99 (in Persian).
Fotohi, S., Taghizadeh, Z., Rahimi, D., 2012. Evaluation of geomorpho-tourism capabilities of landforms based on the Prolong method, case study: Biston tourism sample area. Appl. Res. of Geogr. Sci. (Geographical Sciences). 12(26), 23-46.
Gerami, Z., Arabkhedri, M., Asadi, H., Bayat, R., 2017. Suspended sediment changes under the influence of rainfall erosivity cycle in Sorkhab Watershed. Iran. J. Watershed Manage. Sci. Engin. 11(38), 61-72.
Gerami, Z., Arabkhedri, M., Karimi, A., Asadi, H., 2022a. An appropriate weighting factor for calculating sediment connectivity index in bare tilled soils. Watershed Manage. Res. J. 35(3), 114-130.
Gerami, Z., Arabkhedri, M., Karimi, A., Asadi, H., 2022b. A review of fundamentals and applications of sediment connectivity index in soil erosion studie. Iran. J. Soil Water Res. 53(9), 2191-2208.
Gharakhlou, M., Tavakoli Naghmeh, M.T.N., Garousi, A., 2020. Identify the location of the camp of religious tourism and leisure city with AHP and fuzzy logic in GIS (The holy city of Qom). Tour. Manag. Stud. 15(51), 207-228.
Ghiasi Noeei, M., 2012. Locating the sample tourism area of Abarde using GIS software and AHP model. The First National Conference of Tourism Management, Nature Tourism and Geography (in Persian).
Ghorbanzadeh, O., Pourmoradian, S., Blaschke, T., Feizizadeh, B., 2019. Mapping potential nature-based tourism areas by applying GIS-decision making systems in east Azerbaijan Province Iran. J. Ecotouris. 18(3), 261-283.
Halabian, A.H., Azizi, M., Azadeh, H., Karimzadeh, S., 2012. Capability measurement of selected geomorphosites of Tehran province using the Prolong method. The Second National Conference on Tourism and Nature Tourism in Iran.
Hosseini, A., Heydari, F., Parsa, A., 2013. Optimum positioning of press kiosks in Rasht city using AHP method in GIS environment. National Conference of Architecture, Civil Engineering and Modern Urban Development, Tabriz. National Center of Iranian Architectural Engineers Associations (in Persian).
Ildrumi, A., Hosseini, M., Ghorbani, M., 2019. Feasibility of creating an eco-tourism camp at Balkhali Bolaghi resort in Garmab city. Tour. Manag. Stud. 15(51), 175-209 (in Persian).
Jalilvand, H., Karami, O., Shahnazari, A., Shabani, M., 2011. Tourism evaluation with the help of Analysis Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Geographical Information System (GIS) - Case: Shahid Zare Forest Park, Mazandaran. Geograph. Develop. 10(29), 107-118 (in Persian).
Jam, A.S., Mosaffaie, J., 2023. Introducing the concept of a ladder of watershed management: A stimulus to promote watershed management approaches. Environ. Sci. Policy. 147, 315-325.
Jam, A.S., Tabatabaei, M.R., Mosaffaie, J., 2022. Barriers to participatory implementation of soil conservation projects: Perspectives and priorities. Environ. Sci. Policy. 131, 36-45.
Jamali, A.A., Tabatabaee, R., Randhir, T.O., 2021. Ecotourism and socioeconomic strategies for Khansar River watershed of Iran. Environ. Dev. Sustain. 23(11), 17077-17093.
Jamini, D., Dehghani, A., 2022. Evaluation and analysis of resilience of rural tourism and identification of key drivers affecting it in the face of the Covid-19 pandemic in Iran. J. Res. Rural Plan. 11(4), 99-116.
Kamali, M., Azarnivand, H., Malekian, A., Mosaffaei, J., 2023. Developing management solutions for Alolak watershed in the Qazvin Province using the DPSIR approach. J. Watershed Manag. Res. 14 (28), 148-162.
Karami, O., Mahdavi, A., Hosseini Nasr, M., Jalilund, H., 2014. Evaluating areas prone to ecotourism using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), case study: Babolrud watershed, Mazandaran. Wood Forest Sci. Technol. Res. 21(2), 185-202 (in Persian).
Maghsoudi, M., Faraji Sabokar, H.A., Parvaz, Ha., Behnam Morshedi, H., 2014. Locating ecotourism development areas in Kavir National Park using GIS and Genetic Algorith. Hum. Geogr. Stud. 47(2), 367-390 (in Persian).
Mokhtari, D., 2014. Geotourism. Tabriz University, Tabriz.
Momeni, M., Taghi Pourjavi, M., Mostaghathi, Sh., 2013. Optimum location of tourism sample areas (case study: Sistan and Baluchistan Province). Geogr. J. Tour. Space. 8, 113-141 (in Persian).
Mosaffaie, .J, Talebi, A., 2014. A statistical view to the water erosion in Iran. Ext. Dev. Watershed Mgmt. 2(5), 9-17 (in Persian).
Mousavi, S.H., Nazari, N., Gholami, Y., 2019. Spatial analysis and capability assessment of tourism susceptible zones in Fasa County. Geogr. Envr. Plan. 29(4), 145-168 (in Persian).
Nadali, N., 2019. Location of tourist campsites in the city of Isfahan using geographic information system (GIS). Master's Degree in Geography and Tourism Planning. Isfahan University.
Nas, C., Ilham, W., 2021. Mapping leading local culture of cirebon tourism sector using geographic information system (GIS). J. Teknologi Dan Open Source. 4(1), 19-27.
Noor, H., Salehpour Jam, A., Rajai, S.H., 2022. Comparison of effective factors on preventing participation of rural societies in watershed management plans based on local people and experts viewpoints. Watershed Engr. Mgmt. 12(1), 400-411.
Omidzadeh, H., Yari, A. Roshan Ali, M., 2014. Evaluation of geomorphotourism capabilities and priorities using the Prolong method, case study: Lorestan province. Urban Eco Res. Qtly. 5(9), 9-28.
Özdemir Işık, B., Demir, S., 2017. Integrated multi-criteria decision-making methods for the sustainability of historical-cultural structures on the Trabzon Coastline. Sustain. 9(11), 14-21.
Rabet, A., Rostamizad, G., Salehpour Jam, A., 2023. Investigating the obstacles to the participation of local communities in the process of implementing watershed and natural resources projects, Arpachai Watershed, Zanjan Province. Watershed Eng. Mgmt. 15(4), 622-638.
Rashidi, M., Ghanbari, Y., Karimi, J., 2014. Web location of information kiosks in urban tourism destinations. J. Tour. Mgmt. Stud. 10 (32), 89-109 (in Persian).
Rashvand, S., Mosafaee, J., Darvish, M., 2013. Investigation on potential of desertification in terms of decay of vegetation. Case study: rude shoor, Qazvin. Iranian J. Range Desert Res. 20, 38-49.
Razavizadeh, N., Varshoe, S., 2023. A formal and contentual review of pilgrimage and religious tourism studies in Iran (2003-2021). J. Social Studies Tour. 11(22), 93-132 (in Persian).
Rezaei, P., 2017. Locating nomadic tourism sites (case study: Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari Province). Hum. Settlements Plan. Stud. 13(4), 951-969 (in Persian).
Rezvani, M., Oroji, H., Alizadeh M., Najafi, M., 2013. Locating the construction of ski resorts from the perspective of tourism (case study: northern areas of Tehran province). Reg. plan. 10, 25-43 (in Persian).
Rostami, Sh., Abkar, F., 2013. Locating tourism uses using geographic information systems (GIS) case study: Locating a happy park in Kish Island. Geogr. Urban-Regional Stud. 5, 35-48 (in Persian).
Saadatpour Alvigh, R., Khoshdel, K., 2013. Evaluation of the geoneurological capabilities of the geomorphological places of Varzeghan city using the Prolong method. The First Conference of Geographical Sciences of Iran.
Salehpour Jam, A., Mosaffaie, J., Tabatabaei, M.R., 2021. Assessment of comprehensiveness of soil conservation measures using the DPSIR framework. Envr. Monitoring Assmt. 193, 1-19.
Salehpour Jam, A., Rasooli, F., Sarreshtehdari, A., Mosaffaie, J. Kianian, M.K., 2020. Prioritization of preventing social indices affecting on peoples' participation in natural resources plans using AHP method and nonparametric tests. Watershed Eng. Mgmt. 12(1), 330-339.
Saligheh, M., Beheshti Javed, I., 2014. Seasonal tourism location zoning in Semiram city based on the comparison of hierarchical analysis method and climatic index. Geogr. 41, 239-255 (in Persian).
Sayadi, F., Moghaddasi, R., 2011, Economic evaluation of environmental friendliness (case study of Vashi gorge and Savashi waterfall tourism area in Firouzkoh city). Renew. Nat. Resour. Res. 2(3), 33-43.
Seidaie, S.S., Sadeghi, H.O., 2023. Locating the construction of nomadic tourism ecocamps in Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari region. Nomadic Terr. Planning Stud. 3(1), 13-30 (in Persian).
Shahdadi, A., Ghanbari, Y., Salmanizadeh, E., Azare, A., 2018. Potential assessment and location of areas susceptible to the construction of nomadic ecocamps (case study: a part of Semiram city). J. Geogr. (Regional Planning). 9(3), 293-306 (in Persian).
Shayan, S., Zare, G.R., Sharifi Kia, M., Amiri, Sh., 2012. Evaluation of tourism potential of geomorphological landforms (case study: Kersia salt dome - Darab plain). Quant. Geomorphol. Res. 4, 119-132.
Siar, R., Amadian, M.A., Jafari, H., Alizadeh, K., 2018. The role of tourism in generating income in rural areas by presenting a strategic modelin the development of rural tourism (case study of Firouzkoh city). Sci-Res. Quart. New Attitudes Hum. Geogr. 10(2), 49-77.
Soltanalizadeh, A., Ramezanzadeh, A., Jalali, M., 2014. Determining appropriate natural caves for underground crude oil storage by admixture FAHP and TOPSIS methods. J. Engr. Geol. 8(3), 2239-2260.
Taheri Bejgan, S., Hadi Asl, F., Asiqlani, P., 2013. Locating tourist sites in Bandar Abbas to create a touristic atmosphere, Urban Tour. J. 1(1), 113-126 (in Persian).
Varesi, H.R., Rezaei, M., 2011. Spatial analysis and location of accommodation centers in historical cities (case study: Shiraz city hotels). Amash Mohit Quarterly. Islamic Azad University, Malair Branch. 19, 1-26 (in Persian).
Yamani, M., Negahban, S., Rahimi Harabadi, S., Alizadeh, M., 2013. Geomorphotourism and comparison of geomorphosite evaluation methods in tourism development, case study: Hormozgan Province. J. Tour. Plan. Dev. 1(1), 83-104.